Notched Impact Strength: Izod, Charpy, and Plastic Selection Guide
Need Custom Components?
Looking for a direct China factory for plastic or hardware parts?
Your Direct China Manufacturer
In-house production for custom plastic and hardware parts.
What Notched Impact Strength Actually Measures
The most common misconception is that a high notched impact strength automatically means an injection molded part will not crack. It does not. A notched impact test measures how much energy a standardized specimen absorbs when a sudden load is applied to a deliberately created stress concentrator. It is a controlled indicator of impact resistance and notch sensitivity, not a complete prediction of every real-world failure.

From a manufacturing perspective, this distinction matters. A plastic housing, tool accessory, bracket, or structural component may fail because of a sharp internal corner, weld line, ejector mark, incorrect gate position, low temperature, chemical exposure, or an assembly force that is repeated many times. A material with a strong laboratory result can still fail when the molded part has poor geometry or inconsistent processing.
Notched impact strength is usually expressed as energy absorbed during fracture. Depending on the applicable standard, results may be reported in joules per meter, foot-pounds per inch, or kilojoules per square meter. These units and test methods are not interchangeable without checking the specimen geometry, notch dimensions, conditioning, impact direction, and calculation method.
Notched versus unnotched impact performance
An unnotched specimen shows how a material behaves without a deliberately introduced crack starter. A notched specimen creates a much more severe and repeatable stress concentration. Comparing the two can help engineers understand how sensitive a grade is to scratches, corners, holes, weld lines, and other discontinuities.
The result should not be treated as a simple universal ratio. A material can show good unnotched impact performance but a much lower notched value if it is highly notch-sensitive. Conversely, rubber-modified grades may maintain better energy absorption after the notch is introduced. The practical decision is whether the selected grade remains reliable under the actual part geometry and service conditions.
Notched Izod and Notched Charpy: What Is the Difference?
Notched Izod and notched Charpy are both pendulum impact methods, but they do not use the same specimen support or impact arrangement. The test name, standard, specimen dimensions, notch orientation, conditioning procedure, and reporting unit must all be included when an impact value is specified.
| Test method | Common standard | Typical engineering use | Important purchasing and quality points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Notched Izod | ASTM D256 or ISO 180 | Evaluating the impact resistance of plastic specimens supported in a cantilever arrangement | ASTM D256 and ISO 180 results should not be treated as equivalent. Confirm notch geometry, specimen type, conditioning, impact direction, and reporting unit. |
| Notched Charpy | ISO 179-1 or ASTM D6110 | Evaluating impact resistance with a specimen supported at both ends | Confirm whether the result is from a notched or unnotched specimen and whether the reported value is based on the relevant cross-sectional area. |
| Supplier material data | Grade-specific datasheet or test report | Initial comparison of candidate resin grades | Use the value for screening only until the grade, color, additives, conditioning, and production molding conditions are confirmed. |
| Production validation | Project-agreed standard and laboratory procedure | Checking molded specimens or finished components under representative conditions | Record lot, molding orientation, temperature, humidity, specimen location, and fracture mode. Do not mix laboratory plaques with production parts without correlation. |

ASTM D256 is widely associated with the notched Izod test, while ISO 180 is another recognized Izod method. ISO 179-1 and ASTM D6110 are commonly associated with Charpy testing of plastics. The methods may produce different numerical values for the same resin grade because the stress state and specimen arrangement are different.
For an international supply project, the drawing or quality agreement should state the complete requirement rather than simply saying “impact resistant.” A useful specification identifies the standard, specimen type, notch condition, test temperature, conditioning state, minimum value, and whether the requirement applies to the raw material, molded test bars, or finished component.
How Plastic Materials Compare Under Notched Impact
Material selection should begin with the service environment and failure risk, not with the highest number found in a datasheet. Resin family, grade formulation, colorant, reinforcement, flame-retardant package, moisture condition, and molding direction can all change plastic impact strength.
- ABS: General-purpose ABS often provides a practical balance of impact resistance, stiffness, appearance, and injection molding processability. It is commonly considered for housings, covers, handles, and functional structural parts, but the exact grade and temperature range still control performance.
- HIPS: High-impact polystyrene uses a rubber-modified structure to improve impact resistance compared with general-purpose polystyrene. It can be cost-effective for less demanding components, but chemical resistance, heat performance, and long-term durability must be checked for the application.
- Polycarbonate: PC grades are often selected when high impact resistance and stiffness are important. They may also support demanding dimensional requirements, but material cost, drying requirements, residual stress, and sensitivity to certain chemicals should be considered.
- PC/ABS: PC/ABS blends can provide a useful balance between impact performance, processability, appearance, and cost. The balance varies significantly between grades, particularly when flame retardants or other additives are included.
- Polypropylene: Copolymer PP grades can offer good impact performance at low density, especially when the grade is selected for low-temperature service. Flow direction, weld lines, wall thickness, and temperature can strongly affect the result.
- PA6 and PA66: Polyamide grades are sensitive to moisture conditioning. A dry specimen may be more brittle, while absorbed moisture can increase toughness and reduce stiffness. The test condition must reflect how the finished part will be stored and used.
- POM: Acetal is valued for wear resistance, dimensional behavior, and repeated mechanical movement. It should not automatically be treated as a high-impact material, particularly when a sharp notch, thin section, or low-temperature load is involved.
- Glass-filled grades: Glass fiber can increase stiffness and dimensional stability, but fibers may create local stress concentrations and directional behavior. A filled grade may therefore have lower notched impact performance than its unfilled counterpart, depending on formulation and flow orientation.
Rubber modifiers generally improve energy absorption, while mineral fillers, some flame-retardant systems, and high reinforcement levels can reduce impact performance. These are not absolute rules for every grade, so supplier data and project testing remain necessary.
A Practical Workflow for Using a Notched Impact Test
Define the real failure condition
Start by identifying how the component may be damaged. A part dropped onto a hard floor has a different requirement from a bracket exposed to a sudden assembly load. A tool accessory used outdoors may see cold temperatures, moisture, oils, or repeated impacts. A housing may be loaded at a screw boss or snap-fit feature rather than across its main wall.
Record the expected temperature range, impact direction, assembly condition, chemical exposure, wall thickness, stress concentration, and required service life. If the real concern is repeated loading, fatigue or cyclic testing may be more relevant than a single pendulum impact value.
Select the test method before comparing values
Choose notched Izod or notched Charpy according to the project standard, customer requirement, and available reference data. Do not compare an ASTM D256 value from one grade directly with an ISO 179 value from another grade and call the higher number better.
Also confirm whether the test is performed at room temperature or at a specified low temperature. Some plastics retain toughness at room temperature but become substantially more brittle in cold conditions. A material screening decision based only on room-temperature data may create a serious design risk.
Shortlist complete material grades
Request the exact commercial grade, not only the resin family. The specification should identify whether the material is reinforced, flame retardant, impact modified, recycled, UV stabilized, or blended with another polymer. Color can also affect formulation and process conditions, so a clear natural grade and a production color should not be assumed to behave identically without confirmation.
When the part is safety-relevant or difficult to redesign, compare at least one conventional grade and one higher-impact alternative. The higher-impact grade may increase resin cost or alter shrinkage, surface appearance, cycle time, or mold filling behavior. That trade-off should be evaluated before tooling is finalized.
Mold representative specimens and parts
Impact bars molded under laboratory conditions can provide useful material data, but they may not represent a production component. Production parts have gates, weld lines, variable wall thickness, ribs, bosses, inserts, and molded-in stress. A robust validation plan checks both standard specimens and critical part features when the risk justifies it.
For injection molding, document the material lot, drying condition where applicable, barrel temperature, mold temperature, injection speed, packing conditions, cooling time, and regrind usage. The purpose is not to force one universal process window, but to establish whether the tested result reflects the process that will be used for mass production.
Check flow direction and molded-in defects
Polymer orientation can make impact behavior directional. A specimen cut parallel to the flow may behave differently from one cut across the flow. Weld lines can be particularly important because they may contain weaker molecular entanglement or local contamination and can become the starting point for fracture.
Gate placement should be reviewed when a high-impact load is applied near a boss, clip, hinge, or mounting hole. A gate that creates a weld line at the load path may produce cracking even when the resin has acceptable notched impact strength. Sharp internal corners should also be replaced with practical radii where the design permits.
Condition and interpret the specimens correctly
Plastic results depend on temperature and humidity history. Hygroscopic materials such as nylon require special attention because drying and moisture conditioning can produce materially different behavior. The agreed conditioning procedure should be followed consistently, and the result should identify whether the specimen was dry-as-molded, dried, or moisture conditioned.
Do not evaluate only the average value. Review individual results, dispersion, and fracture appearance. A wide spread can indicate inconsistent molding, specimen dimensions, moisture state, orientation, or material quality. Fracture through a weld line or a brittle, clean break may require a different corrective action from a ductile fracture that absorbs substantial energy.
How Injection Molding Changes Plastic Impact Strength
The resin selected for a project is only one part of the result. Molding conditions influence crystallinity, molecular orientation, residual stress, weld-line quality, and the internal structure of the finished part.
Insufficient drying can cause hydrolytic degradation in moisture-sensitive materials, reducing molecular weight and potentially lowering toughness. Excessive shear or an unsuitable melt temperature can also damage some grades. On the other hand, poor filling, inadequate packing, or an unsuitable mold temperature may create internal stress and weak knit lines.
Cooling and ejection are also relevant. A part removed too early may distort or retain higher residual stress. Ejector pins located near thin walls, bosses, or impact zones can leave marks that become practical crack initiators. These defects may not appear in a smooth, laboratory-molded test bar.
For a component that must pass a notched impact requirement, engineers should review the complete tool design, including gate type, runner balance, venting, cooling layout, draft, corner radii, ejector arrangement, and likely weld-line positions. Tool changes made after production release can affect cost and delivery, so high-risk impact features should be reviewed during DFM and sample development.
Cost and Procurement Implications
A higher notched impact value does not always produce the lowest total cost. An impact-modified or PC-based grade may cost more per kilogram, require more careful drying, or have different shrinkage and cycle behavior. However, the additional resin cost may be justified if it prevents field cracking, repeated mold changes, or a redesign of a snap-fit or mounting feature.
Conversely, selecting an expensive high-impact grade for a protected indoor component may add cost without improving the actual failure risk. If the main problem is a sharp corner, poor weld-line location, or excessive assembly interference, correcting the design or process may be more effective than changing the resin.
Purchasing teams should include the following information in an RFQ or quality agreement:
- The exact resin grade and approved alternatives, including reinforcement, color, flame-retardant status, and recycled content requirements.
- The required notched Izod or notched Charpy standard, specimen condition, test temperature, unit, and minimum acceptance value.
- Whether the requirement applies to supplier plaques, molded test bars, production parts, or a specific critical feature.
- The permitted process changes after approval, including material substitution, regrind percentage, gate relocation, and major molding parameter changes.
- The sampling, lot traceability, inspection record, and corrective-action process for results below the agreed limit.
A supplier datasheet is useful for initial selection but is not a substitute for project validation. Values may be produced on a particular specimen thickness and under a particular conditioning procedure. They should not be presented as a guaranteed result for every geometry or production lot.
Quality Control and Supplier Evaluation
A capable supplier should be able to explain how the selected grade will be processed, where weld lines are expected, which features carry the impact load, and how production consistency will be monitored. The discussion should connect material data with the actual drawing and mold design.
For an injection molded component, useful review questions include:
- Is the impact requirement based on a recognized standard, and is the standard stated in full?
- Does the proposed material match the approved grade and formulation?
- Are drying, moisture conditioning, and storage requirements controlled?
- Could the gate, weld line, ejector location, or sharp corner weaken the critical area?
- Will the production part have the same wall thickness and flow direction as the validation specimen?
- Are material lots, molding changes, and inspection results traceable?
- Has the part been checked under the temperature and assembly conditions that create the actual risk?
JATERSON approaches notched impact requirements from the perspective of injection molding, hardware production, engineering support, quality control, and production coordination. For general plastic components and functional structural parts, this means reviewing the material grade together with the drawing, tool layout, molding process, sampling plan, and delivery schedule. When a formal laboratory result is required, the buyer and supplier should agree on the applicable standard and a qualified testing arrangement before production validation begins.
Key Takeaway for Material and Mold Decisions
Notched impact strength is a valuable comparison tool, but it is meaningful only when the method and application are clearly defined. Notched Izod and notched Charpy results should not be mixed, generic “impact resistant” claims should not replace a grade-specific requirement, and a material result should not be separated from the mold and part design.
The most reliable approach is to define the real impact condition, select the correct test standard, compare complete material grades, mold representative specimens and parts, control moisture and process history, and review the fracture mode as well as the numerical result. This approach gives engineers and buyers a more realistic basis for selecting plastic impact strength, controlling cost, and reducing cracking risk during mass production.
Recent Comments (0) 0
Leave a Reply